Justia U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries

Articles Posted in Labor & Employment Law
by
A group of nine tenured professors at a public Kansas university were terminated after the Kansas Board of Regents (KBOR) temporarily amended its policy, citing COVID-19-related financial pressures. The amendment permitted universities to suspend or terminate tenured faculty without the usual protections, including hearings or proof of financial exigency. ESU administrators drafted a framework for implementing these terminations, which KBOR approved. The professors received termination letters referencing general financial concerns, but allegedly lacking specific reasons. The professors claimed ESU was not facing financial exigency, and that their terminations were motivated by their political activities and beliefs. All nine appealed through the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH); six had their terminations reversed and three had them affirmed. Litigation ensued, with the professors asserting constitutional violations under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, including due process, liberty, association, and equal protection claims.The United States District Court for the District of Kansas denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss most claims, finding that qualified immunity did not bar them. It ruled the professors had adequately alleged deprivation of a property interest in continued employment without due process and allowed other constitutional claims to proceed. The court dismissed liberty interest claims against KBOR and some administrators where no statements were attributed to them, but denied dismissal for others allegedly involved in drafting termination letters.The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the appeal at the motion-to-dismiss stage, adopting facts as alleged. It held that the professors had a state-created property interest in tenure and that the process used to terminate their employment plausibly violated clearly established procedural due process rights. The court affirmed denial of dismissal for procedural due process and related conspiracy claims, but reversed as to substantive due process claims, finding no clearly established violation. It also reversed denial of dismissal for liberty, association, equal protection, and conspiracy claims against KBOR and certain administrators, instructing the district court to dismiss those claims, while leaving claims against the university president intact. View "Miracle v. Hush" on Justia Law

by
A Colorado-based retailer employed a sales associate who, after contracting a severe illness in March 2020 (suspected COVID-19), experienced ongoing and worsening symptoms including gastrointestinal pain, weakness, difficulty breathing, and intermittent inability to speak. She initially received twelve weeks of leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), which was set to expire in June 2020. Before her leave expired, the employee communicated with the company’s human resources specialist about her persistent symptoms and medical procedures, including a scheduled endoscopy. She requested an extension of leave, explaining she needed more time to recover and receive results from her medical tests. The retailer declined to grant additional leave and terminated her employment shortly after the FMLA leave expired.After the termination, the employee filed a discrimination charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which investigated and brought suit against the retailer in the United States District Court for the District of Colorado. The retailer moved for summary judgment, arguing the EEOC had not established the employee had a qualifying disability, had not provided sufficient notice of her disability and limitations, and had requested an unreasonable, indefinite leave. The district court granted summary judgment for the retailer on all claims, finding the employee had not put the company on notice of her disability and her request for an indefinite leave was not a reasonable accommodation.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reversed the district court’s summary judgment. The Tenth Circuit held that a reasonable jury could find the employee provided sufficient notice of her disabling condition and that her request for a few weeks of additional leave constituted a plausibly reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The court remanded for further proceedings. View "EEOC v. A & A Appliance" on Justia Law

by
A group of boilermakers, who were participants in a multi-employer pension plan, sought early retirement benefits after leaving their union jobs before reaching age 65. The plan provided for early retirement if the participant “withdrew completely” and refrained from employment in jobs classified under a collective bargaining agreement or supervising workers in those positions. Some boilermakers took other jobs after retiring, prompting the trustees of the pension plan to deny their early retirement benefits, claiming the participants were ineligible because they had not ceased all employment with companies contributing to the plan.In the United States District Court for the District of Kansas, both parties moved for summary judgment. The district court granted partial summary judgment to the boilermakers on their benefit claims, finding the plan’s language did not require withdrawal from all jobs, only those specified. It also granted partial summary judgment to some boilermakers on fiduciary duty claims, while ruling others were time-barred due to a three-year limitations period. The defendants appealed the grant of summary judgment on the benefits claims, and 66 boilermakers cross-appealed the denial of their fiduciary duty claims.The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the district court’s rulings de novo, applying the arbitrary-and-capricious standard to the plan administrator’s decisions. The court held that the plan’s unambiguous language only required withdrawal from certain jobs, not all employment, and that the administrator’s broader interpretation was arbitrary and capricious. It further held that the defendants could not rely on the limitations period for benefit claims due to inadequate notice to participants. For fiduciary duty claims, the court found the limitations period did not begin until actual knowledge of the breach, reversing summary judgment against the 66 boilermakers. The court affirmed the benefit claims and remanded the fiduciary duty claims for further proceedings. View "Phillips v. Boilermaker-Blacksmith National Pension Trust" on Justia Law

by
Three individuals employed as customer service agents for a ground services provider and an airline at Denver International Airport brought a class action lawsuit asserting violations of Colorado’s wage laws. Their complaint alleged that the employers improperly deducted time for lunch breaks not taken, forced work during rest breaks, failed to pay overtime, and withheld commissions. Each employee’s contract contained a mandatory arbitration clause, which the employers sought to enforce under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and Colorado law. The employees responded that, as transportation workers, their contracts were exempt from the FAA, and further argued that Colorado law voided such arbitration agreements for wage claims.The United States District Court for the District of Colorado denied the motions to compel arbitration. After an evidentiary hearing, the district court focused narrowly on the specific duties of the three employees, rather than considering the work typically performed by the broader class of customer service agents. It found that the employees “actually and routinely” handled passenger luggage and played a “gatekeeping” role with respect to cargo. On this basis, the court concluded they were transportation workers exempt from the FAA. The district court did not address the request to compel arbitration under Colorado law.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit held that the district court erred by defining the relevant class of workers too narrowly—focusing only on the specific employees, rather than the typical duties of the class as a whole, as required by Supreme Court precedent (including Southwest Airlines Co. v. Saxon). The Tenth Circuit reversed the district court’s order denying the motions to compel arbitration and remanded for further proceedings to properly determine the attributes of the class of workers under the correct legal standard. View "Joyner v. Frontier Airlines" on Justia Law

by
A longtime educator and administrator, the plaintiff began working as a teacher in 1996 and advanced to principal roles in Cherry Creek School District. In 2018, she became principal at High Plains Elementary. After receiving positive evaluations initially, complaints from staff and parents intensified during her second year. The teachers’ union conducted a “Listening Tour,” reporting negative staff feedback, including concerns about division, lack of trust, micromanagement, and fear of retaliation. Subsequent meetings between the plaintiff and her supervisors discussed these concerns and potential remedies. Ultimately, the district’s superintendent decided to demote her to assistant principal, citing loss of staff confidence but no disciplinary or misconduct issues. She took leave and then retired the following year.The plaintiff sued the school district, several administrators, and board members in the United States District Court for the District of Colorado, asserting federal claims under the Fourteenth Amendment (due process and equal protection), the First Amendment, the Equal Pay Act (EPA), and Title IX. The district court granted summary judgment to all defendants on the due process, First Amendment, and EPA claims, and partially on the equal protection and Title IX claims. Only the equal protection claim against three individual administrators (based on disparate treatment) and the Title IX claim against the district (based on disparate treatment and sex stereotyping) proceeded to trial.The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the district court’s rulings and the subsequent judgment as a matter of law. The appellate court affirmed all decisions. The main holdings are: the plaintiff lacked a due process property interest in continued employment as principal; Cherry Creek’s salary determination based on relevant experience was a legitimate, non-discriminatory factor under the EPA; and, after trial, no reasonable jury could find sex or gender was a motivating factor in the plaintiff’s demotion for either equal protection or Title IX claims. View "Maccagnan v. Cherry Creek School District No. 5" on Justia Law

by
A former Walmart employee alleged that he experienced discrimination based on his sexual orientation during his employment, which began in 2017. He described a workplace permeated by anti-gay slurs, derogatory remarks from coworkers and supervisors, and specific incidents such as being compared to a pedophile and bestialist, being subjected to false accusations of inappropriate conduct, and encountering offensive drawings and slurs in common areas. He was demoted from a supervisory position, briefly terminated and then reinstated, and ultimately resigned, citing ongoing harassment and disparate treatment in vacation approvals and work assignments.After the employee filed suit in New Mexico state court, the case was removed to the United States District Court for the District of New Mexico. His claims, brought under Title VII and the New Mexico Human Rights Act, included disparate treatment based on demotion and termination, retaliation for opposing unlawful conduct, hostile work environment, and constructive discharge. The district court granted summary judgment to Walmart on all claims. It found the demotion and termination claims lacking evidence of discrimination or harm, dismissed the retaliation claim for lack of protected activity, rejected the constructive discharge claim for insufficient severity of conditions, and held that the hostile-work-environment claim failed because the incidents were not sufficiently severe or pervasive, and some were improperly excluded as “discrete acts.”On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed the District Court’s judgment on all claims except the hostile-work-environment claim. It held that the demotion-based disparate-treatment claim was barred by the statute of limitations and that the temporary termination claim was not adequately appealed. It also found no evidence of protected opposition to support retaliation or intolerable conditions for constructive discharge. However, the court reversed summary judgment on the hostile-work-environment claim, holding that a reasonable jury could find the alleged conduct sufficiently severe or pervasive, and remanded that claim for further proceedings. View "Sharpe-Miller v. Walmart" on Justia Law

by
A White male employee of the Colorado Department of Corrections was required to attend a racial sensitivity training program that addressed the historical mistreatment of racial minorities. He found the training offensive, alleging that it created a discriminatory and hostile work environment against White employees. The employee claimed that the training included materials and recommendations—such as a glossary and videos—that generalized about the role of all White people in perpetuating racial injustice. He also alleged that, following the training, there was an ongoing commitment to similar programs, that employees were required to endorse the training’s ideology, that supervisors used the training in disciplinary decisions, that the training compromised workplace security, and that the Department failed to investigate his complaints.The United States District Court for the District of Colorado dismissed the employee’s complaint with prejudice for failure to state a claim. The district court found that, even accepting the allegations as true, the facts pleaded did not plausibly show a workplace that was sufficiently hostile under the legal standard required for a hostile work environment claim. The court declined to liberally construe the complaint because it was drafted by counsel.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the dismissal de novo, assuming for argument’s sake that the complaint should be liberally construed. The appellate court held that the employee did not plausibly allege facts sufficient to show that the workplace was permeated with discriminatory intimidation, ridicule, or insult that was severe or pervasive enough to create an abusive working environment. The court also affirmed dismissal of the constructive discharge claim and held that the district court did not abuse its discretion by dismissing the case with prejudice, as the plaintiff failed to address the deficiencies after multiple opportunities to amend. The judgment was affirmed. View "Young v. Colorado Department of Corrections" on Justia Law

by
The plaintiff, who worked as a security supervisor for a company contracted to provide services at an industrial facility, was terminated from his position in June 2020. The employer cited alleged performance issues, including failures related to COVID-19 protocols and training, as the basis for the discharge. Shortly before his termination, the plaintiff had reported his direct supervisor for alleged favoritism toward female employees. The plaintiff argued that his termination was in retaliation for this report, rather than for the stated reasons.After the plaintiff’s termination, he filed suit under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, claiming unlawful retaliation. The United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma granted summary judgment to the employer. It found that the plaintiff failed to provide sufficient evidence to show that the decisionmaker responsible for his termination knew about the protected activity, or that a supervisor with retaliatory animus influenced the decisionmaker (a “cat’s paw” theory). The district court concluded that, without such evidence, there was no causal link between the protected activity and the adverse employment action.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the grant of summary judgment de novo and affirmed the lower court’s decision. The Tenth Circuit held that, to establish a prima facie case of retaliation, the plaintiff must show that the decisionmaker had knowledge of the protected activity or that an individual with retaliatory intent influenced the decision. The court found that the plaintiff did not produce sufficient evidence to show either scenario. The court also clarified that evidence suggesting pretext for the employer’s reasons does not substitute for the required showing of knowledge or causation. Thus, summary judgment for the employer was affirmed. View "Dominguez v. Weiser Security Services" on Justia Law

by
The plaintiff, a senior engineer at a city water-treatment plant, applied for a superintendent position. Despite holding a Ph.D. in engineering and having extensive technical experience, he lacked significant leadership experience. The city’s hiring process initially required a bachelor’s degree in a relevant field, but the city selected a younger, white candidate without a degree who had substantial leadership experience. The plaintiff, a middle-aged man from China, filed a grievance, and the city’s civil-service commission determined that the city had violated its written hiring policies by certifying candidates without the required degree. In response, the city revised the job description, removing the degree requirement and allowing work experience to substitute for education, then repeated the hiring process, ultimately selecting the same candidate.The plaintiff pursued claims in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, alleging race and age discrimination under Title VII, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and the Oklahoma Anti-Discrimination Act, as well as retaliation. The district court granted summary judgment to the city on all remaining claims, finding that the plaintiff failed to create a genuine issue of material fact regarding pretext and did not establish a prima facie case of retaliation.The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision. The Tenth Circuit held that the plaintiff did not submit evidence from which a reasonable jury could find that the city’s stated preference for leadership experience was pretext for unlawful discrimination. The court found no sufficient evidence of procedural irregularities or subjectivity to support an inference of pretext, nor an overwhelming disparity in qualifications. The Tenth Circuit further held that the plaintiff failed to show pretext for retaliation, as the city’s explanation for changing the job requirements was not contradicted. The district court’s judgment was affirmed. View "Jiang v. City of Tulsa" on Justia Law

by
The plaintiff, who was in his mid-fifties and had decades of restaurant industry experience, was employed by the defendant as a field leader, overseeing several restaurants. He was recognized as a top performer in 2021, with high scores on cleanliness and safety audits. In early 2022, a severe cockroach infestation was reported at one of his assigned restaurants. The infestation was not previously known to him, and he took steps to address it once notified. However, his supervisor observed persistent pest and cleanliness problems at this and other locations within his responsibility. Additionally, site audits found that several of his restaurants failed to meet cleanliness standards within a single week.After these incidents, the plaintiff was terminated for failing to maintain company food safety standards and for not reporting critical breaches promptly. He received termination documentation and final warnings simultaneously. The plaintiff later sued under the New Mexico Human Rights Act, alleging that his termination was due to age discrimination. The defendant removed the case to the United States District Court for the District of New Mexico, which granted summary judgment for the employer, holding that the plaintiff had not shown sufficient evidence that the stated reasons for his firing were a pretext for age discrimination.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reviewed the case de novo. The court held that the plaintiff did not present enough evidence that the employer’s justification was pretextual. The evidence failed to show that younger employees with comparable problems were treated more favorably or that the employer’s stated reasons were false or inconsistent. The court emphasized that it would not second-guess business decisions absent evidence of discrimination. The Tenth Circuit affirmed the district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of the employer. View "Sousa v. Chipotle Services" on Justia Law